In 1833 Mrs. Frances Silver was hanged in Morganton, North Carolina, for the ax murder of her husband Charles. For a century and a half the case has lived on in newspapers, pamphlets, memoirs, petitions, legends, a Sharyn McCrumb novel, plays, a ballet, documentary films, websites, and folksong scholarship. Did Frankie have cause to act or hope of justice? The Ballad of Frankie Silver explores the case through the singing and stories of Bobby McMillon and the comments of North Carolina Assistant Attorney General Jeffrey Gray and others.
Bobby McMillon, the recipient of a North Carolina Folk Heritage Award, is a member of the Silver family and learned stories about Frankie as he grew up in the community where the murder took place. In the epilogue Making of the Ballad Singer (begins at 36:25), Bobby and his singing partner Marina Trivette tell how they developed a love for Appalachian ballads and tales as children.
The video was directed by Tom Davenport and produced with folklorist Daniel Patterson. Patterson's book A Tree Accurst: Bobby McMillon and Stories of Frankie Silver, won the 2001 Chicago Folklore Prize. Through the Frankie Silver material it explores the interplay between folklore, social and personal history, law, and narrative conventions as people try to understand human character and fate.
Bobby McMillon performs in a CD Lords and Merry Maids All: Mountain Love Songs and Child Ballads. Available from Ivycreek.com which also carries other recordings of authentic mountain music.
More About This Film
- The Ballad of Frankie Silver Transcription
- BOBBY McMILLON’S TALL TALE, Transcription and Commentary
- Ballad of Frankie Silver, Frankie's Confession
- Excerpt from "A Fly in Amber: Faded Leaves of Time"
- The Ballad and the Legends of Frankie Silver: A Search for the Woman's Voice
- Making the Ballad of Frankie Silver
- "Give Me the Truth!": The Frankie Silver Story in Contemporary North Carolina
- Suggested Readings and Recordings
Almeda Riddle: Now Let's Talk about Singing1985 | 28 mins
Buna and Bertha1973 | 13 mins
Madison County Project2005 | 24 mins
Bessie Eldreth1996 | 28 mins
The End of an Old Song1969 | 30 mins
Mountain Talk2003 | 56 mins
"The Other Side of Eden" trailer2018 | 1 mins
Hansel and Gretel: An Appalachian Version1975 | 15 mins
The Other Side of Eden: Stories of a Virginia Lynching2018 | 59 mins